Skip to main content

Dealing with a Legal Challenge? Don't wait. Ask your legal question for free. Urgent legal matters require immediate attention!

Rental Car Stolen at Coney Island Beach: Who Pays?

This legal question related to Automobile accident attorneys in New York has been answered.


My car was stolen at Coney Island, and I'm covered by my personal auto insurance. How does this work with the rental company's policy?

Last weekend, I decided to take a trip to Coney Island with my family. We rented a car from a reputable rental company and parked it at a designated spot close to the beach. We were careful and made sure to lock it and didn't leave any valuables in plain sight. After a few hours of enjoying the beach and rides, we returned to find our rental car missing. The police were informed, and they are looking into the matter. Now, my personal auto insurance policy does cover theft, but I'm not sure how this plays out since it's a rental car. Will the rental company's insurance take precedence over mine? Can I claim from both policies? How do I find the right lawyer for this situation? How much will it cost me?

Commonly posted questions...

A close-up, vibrant and positive image reflecting the theme of insurance and legal advice in an accident scenario. The image should depict a professional setting, perhaps a comforting and reassuring environment of a legal or insurance office. There should be elements symbolizing protection and support, like a shield or a safety net, incorporated subtly in the decor, emphasizing the theme of security and assistance in legal matters. The colors should be realistic yet leaning towards a warm and inviting palet Is it normal for insurance to deny coverage for a hit-and-run in Atlanta?
6 months 3 weeks ago, Automobile accident attorneys, Atlanta

Legal Solution

The response provided below is specific to Automobile accident attorneys in the jurisdiction of New York. If the response is inadequate, please submit a detailed inquiry.

Overlap between Personal and Rental Insurance

It's essential to understand the interplay between your personal auto insurance and the rental car company's policy when a theft occurs. Generally, your personal auto insurance will act as a secondary insurance, covering what the rental company's insurance doesn't. However, the specifics can vary based on your policy's terms and the rental agreement you signed.

Relevant Legal References:

Potential Solutions

  1. Contact your insurance company: Inform them of the theft and provide all necessary documentation, such as police reports and rental agreements. They will guide you on the next steps and clarify the overlap with the rental car's insurance.

  2. Engage with the rental company: Ensure you have a copy of the rental agreement and understand the company's policy on theft. The company will likely claim from their insurance first.

  3. If you feel overwhelmed, consider reaching out to personal injury lawyers who often handle cases involving vehicle theft and accidents.

Average Costs for Legal Help in New York:

Service Average Price ($)
Initial Consultation 150 - 250
Legal Representation (minor cases) 1,000 - 3,000
Legal Representation (complex cases) 5,000 - 10,000

Note: Prices can vary depending on the lawyer's experience, the complexity of your case, and other factors unique to the New York area.

More Information Needed

To give you a more precise answer, we'd need some additional details. It's essential to understand the specifics of your case to provide accurate advice.

  • Were any valuables left inside the car?
  • Did you purchase additional insurance from the rental company?
  • Have you been in a similar situation before?

Commonly Asked Questions:

Q1: Will my insurance rates increase after a theft claim?

Generally, a theft claim on your insurance might lead to an increase in premiums, especially if the claim amount is significant.

Q2: Does the rental company hold me responsible for the theft?

It depends on the rental agreement you signed. Typically, you are responsible only for the deductible, but each agreement varies.

Q3: How long does it take for an insurance claim to process?

The processing time can vary but generally takes a few weeks to a couple of months, depending on the complexity of the claim.

Q4: Can I rent another car in the meantime?

Most insurance policies offer rental car coverage, which allows you to rent another vehicle while your claim is being processed.

Q5: What if the stolen car is recovered after I've made a claim?

If the car is recovered and returned to the rental company, they might close the claim. Any compensation you received might need to be returned, especially if the car is undamaged.

U.S. Auto Insurance Rate Comparison

Insurance Company Average Price Before Theft ($) Average Price After Theft ($) Percentage Increase (%)
State Farm 1,200 1,440 20%
GEICO 1,100 1,320 20%
Progressive 1,250 1,500 20%
Allstate 1,300 1,560 20%
Liberty Mutual 1,150 1,380 20%

Note: The prices mentioned are estimates, and the actual rates can vary based on several factors, including location, driving history, and more.

If you have more questions, don't hesitate to ask a free legal question or compare lawyers in your area to get the best possible assistance.


This content is for informational purposes only and does not establish an attorney-client relationship. It's always recommended to consult with a local attorney about your specific situation.

Written, answered, changed

Legal question "Rental Car Stolen at Coney Island Beach: Who Pays?" has been changed 8 months 3 weeks ago. Demonstrate your legal skills and willingness to help and answer right now! Issue is related to the location of New York & area of law: Automobile accident attorneys.
Latest reviews & rating
Can't believe there are no comments (answers) yet? You can be the first author. Let us know what you think and answer this question.. Write a comment

Seeking the counsel of a personal injury attorney is paramount after vehicular accidents resulting in substantial injuries or necessitating long-term medical care. Engaging an adept attorney amplifies your likelihood of securing rightful compensation. Retaining a personal injury attorney immediately post-accident ensures you have an expert advocating for you - someone well-versed in the nuanced legal landscape and critical procedural rules that could profoundly influence your claim.

A lawyer's proficiency in this domain can often be gauged by their litigation success rate, meticulous pre-trial preparation, and adept negotiation prowess with opposing parties. While certain car accident scenarios may entail complexities around insurance coverage limits, seasoned attorneys might use the potential of litigation as leverage. Yet, more often than not, a skilled attorney can broker a settlement without resorting to court. Why engage a car accident attorney? Overlooking this crucial step could culminate in significant financial setbacks, particularly if either party involved in the accident lacks adequate insurance coverage, resulting in the insurance company disputing or denying the claim.

Respond to legal question!

Do you know the answer to a legal question that is related to the field of law called Automobile accident attorneys? If you believe that you can advise the inquirer – in even the slightest way – do not hesitate and share your opinion in the comment section. This contribution concerns the location of New York and, therefore, it is important to post only comments that are relevant to this location. Do you have a similar or a different legal inquiry? Select the correct category, fill in all the required fields, and submit your post.
accident & property damage attorneys accountants-certified public administrative & governmental law... admiralty & maritime law attorneys adoption law attorneys adoption services attorneys antitrust law attorneys appellate practice attorneys arbitration & mediation attorneys arbitration services asbestos & chemical law attorneys automobile accident attorneys bankruptcy law attorneys bankruptcy services business litigation attorneys child custody attorneys child support collections civil litigation & trial law attorneys collection agencies collection law attorneys commercial law attorneys construction law attorneys consumer law attorneys contract law attorneys copying & duplicating service corporation & partnership law attorneys credit & debt counseling Criminal defense attorney disability services discrimination & civil rights law... divorce assistance divorce attorneys domestic violence attorneys drug charges attorneys dui & dwi attorneys employment discrimination attorneys family law attorneys federal law attorneys financial services franchise law attorneys general practice attorneys government offices immigration law attorneys insurance attorneys international law attorneys labor & employment law attorneys medical law attorneys medical malpractice attorneys paralegals patent (intellectual property) personal injury law attorneys probate (estate planning) probate law attorneys sex offense attorneys sexual harassment attorneys tax attorneys trademark & copyright law traffic law attorneys trusts & estate planning... wrongful death attorneys
Are you having trouble finding a reliable and highly-rated attorney in your area of residence? Does the endless process of browsing and comparing law firms annoy you? If so, simply skip this step and post your request (or a general legal question) in our Free Legal Advice Center. Then wait for a reply from our experienced legal advisors, consultants or even your chosen lawyers. You can inquire about anything concerning your case, as well as questions about judicial issues in your state.

Comments: answer this question

"Rental Car Stolen at Coney Island Beach: Who Pays?"

Automobile accident attorneys New York

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
I agree with Terms & Privacy Policy
Enter the characters shown in the image.

New York advocates and law firms from our database!

© 2016